Maybe This Time:
April Rhodes and Rachel Berry (Kristen Chenoweth & Lea Michele)
Original Song: Liza Minnelli
Episode: Five, The Rhodes Not Taken

Will introduces April to everyone in Glee.  They think she’s old so she shows them what she can do and sings Maybe This Time for them.  While she is singing, the scene flashes to Rachel also singing the song.

Listen:

Purchase: